Not sure I buy into this, but a mention on twitter of WOTC's 3 pillers of RPG (Exploration, Roleplaying and Combat) popped it into my mind. (EDIT: Dave rightly points out that Wizards views these as the three pillars of D&D, a subtle but important distinction)
What I find interesting about this is that I tend to think in terms of the three overlapping areas when I consider gaming styles: Sandbox, Tactics, and Cinematic. I could happily play a game that focused 40/40/20 of Sandbox/Cinematic/Tactics.ReplyDelete
@Cam Yeah, I as I was filling in the overlap sections I had much the same thought.ReplyDelete
I am already mentally "Tacking" various RPGs onto that diagram.ReplyDelete
Well that and how much I want a "Charmed RPG"...
I'll make a pedantic point and say that WotC views those as the three pillars of D&D, not of RPGs in general.ReplyDelete
@cam and @rob: Me three.ReplyDelete
It makes sense why we make/play the kind of games we make/play, eh?
Not sure if it quite works as a Venn diagram (because I think I'm hearing two distinct versions of "Combat" when I do), but it definitely works as a list:ReplyDelete
Sandbox => Roleplay & Explore
Cinematics => Roleplay & Combat
Tactics => Combat & Explore
Although I'd probably change Tactics to "Problem-Solving" myself.
If we're talking the OSR sandbox definitions, I don't see roleplaying as being a key element. The idea that players decide where they go, yeah, that's absolutely exploration, but you can privilege either combat or roleplaying within that. Non-D&D sandboxes might be another issue.ReplyDelete
Likewise I'm wondering what's actually tactical about exploration. Tactics seems to live firmly inside combat, no?
Which leaves me thinking that in the D&D context Combat is very well supported, Exploration is reasonably well supported, but Roleplay is not well supported at all. That matches the degree of mechanical support available for sure.
I consider tactics to require an element of exploration because good tactical play involves setting engagement on a micro rather than macro scale. Without that, it ends up abstract.ReplyDelete
Really Good PostReplyDelete
We provide quality Tactical Camera to our customers with affordable prices. At our site, you will also be amazed with our excellent .http://bit.ly/uKAIsw